Ashay Sewlall and Caster SemenyaAshay Sewlall and Caster Semenya. Picture: Supplied

After staging a dramatic return to the beach as the newly formed Team Orange, Olympic gold medallist Caster Semenya and her teammate Ashay Sewlall have been eliminated from SABC 1’s Tropika Island of Treasure: La Réunion for a second time.

Their exit followed last week’s tense cliffhanger, which saw both Team Orange and Team Litchi (Lalela Mswane and Sesimphiwe ‘Sesi’ Mbatha) land elimination tokens, sending the two pairs straight into a do-or-die elimination challenge.

Set against the backdrop of Réunion Island’s historic Sugar Mill Ruins, the teams faced ‘Lava Layers’, a puzzle challenge that tested their speed, teamwork and problem-solving abilities.

Caster and Ashay in action during the competition's puzzle challenge. Picture: Supplied
Caster and Ashay in action during the competition’s puzzle challenge. Picture: Supplied

Puzzle trouble for Team Orange

Tied together at the waist, contestants had to race between two sides of the mill, collecting eight stackable puzzle pieces, one at a time, to complete a nine-piece structure. With one piece positioned at the starting point, teams had to find the correct pieces to fit into the puzzle. If a piece didn’t fit, they had to return it and try another. Only once a piece was correctly placed could they move on to the next, with the first team to stack all nine pieces securing the win.

Both teams got off to a strong start, but Team Litchi soon found their rhythm. Rather than rushing back and forth, they took time to assess the holes in the puzzle and remember the sequence before heading out to collect their next piece. Their considered approach paid off, allowing them to take the lead and ultimately secure their place in the competition.

For Caster and Ashay, however, puzzles have proven to be a recurring challenge throughout their time on the island. Despite their efforts, the pair were unable to overcome the final obstacle, bringing their journey on Tropika Island Of Treasure to an end for the second time.

Their final words after elimination

Here’s how the pair reacted to their latest elimination:

“Being part of this season of Tropika Island Of Treasure was a great experience. It’s something that I will take as a learning. As in any game, there’s always a winner and a loser and, unfortunately, it proved to be a challenge. However, it was a great experience,” said Caster Semenya.

“I am honestly so grateful. I enjoyed every moment of being a part of this show. I was here to have a good time and enjoy myself and I did that. I am really grateful for the experience,” said Ashay.

Tropika Island Of Treasure airs every Wednesday at 21:00 on SABC 1, with a repeat every Thursday at 18:00 on S3.

HAVE YOU READ THIS ONE?: EXCLUSIVE: Harry Lekwane on Dressing Dineo Moloisane and Mona Monyane for Miss SA 2026

Avatar photo

By Asanda Mbayimbayi

Asanda Mbayimbayi is a multi-award-winning journalist, Lifestyle & Entertainment News Editor, and accomplished storyteller whose work spans digital lifestyle, entertainment, and hard news journalism. Recognised with the prestigious Galliova People's Hero Award in both 2025 and 2026, she has established a distinctive presence in the media landscape through authentic storytelling, editorial excellence, and an ability to connect compelling narratives with the audiences they serve. With a keen instinct for identifying stories that matter and a deep understanding of the relationship between media, culture, and audience engagement, Asanda approaches journalism with a commitment to substance, accuracy, and impact. Her editorial perspective combines the curiosity of an investigative mind with the sensitivity of a storyteller, bringing clarity to complex subjects and depth to stories that shape conversations. Beyond the newsroom, Asanda's expertise extends across research, content creation, production, book editing, and motivational speaking. A qualified Bible teacher, she also draws on her faith and spiritual insight to encourage reflection, personal growth, and meaningful transformation through words. Multifaceted by experience and purpose-driven by conviction, Asanda continues to explore the power of storytelling across platforms and disciplines. Whether shaping editorial narratives, developing compelling content, researching ideas, or inspiring audiences, her work reflects a commitment to thoughtful communication, creative excellence, and stories that leave a lasting impression. At the heart of her work is a belief that storytelling is more than the art of communicating information; it is a powerful tool for informing perspectives, amplifying voices, and creating meaningful connections.