Caster Semenya and her partner Ashay SewlaliCaster Semenya and her partner Ashay Sewlali. Picture: Supplied

Just when contestants thought they knew where they stood in the competition, Tropika Island Of Treasure delivered one of its biggest twists yet!

Caster Semenya made a surprise return to the island, teaming up with Ashay Sewlall to form an all-new Team Orange, while celebrity contestants Sandile Mahlangu and Nadia Nakai saw their journeys come to an unexpected end.

The drama unfolded in an episode which aired on Wednesday, 21:00PM on SABC1 after Team Mango Peach (Sandile Mahlangu and Jodell Tantij) and Team Green Apple (Nadia Nakai and Andile Khuluse) received the dreaded outcome during the Mystery Box Swap, leaving both teams vulnerable and facing possible elimination.

But host Zanele Potelwa had a major surprise up her sleeve. Two previously eliminated teams, Team Orange (Caster Semenya and Thando Zwane) and Team Pineapple (Wiseman Mncube and Ashay Sewlall), were given one more shot at returning to the competition.

A beach challenge delivered an unexpected competition shake-up

The four teams went head-to-head as individuals in the Tropika Reruns challenge, where speed, balance and strategy were key. Contestants had to transport 15 cans of Tropika from one side of the beach to the other using an oar, carrying one, two, three, four and eventually five cans at a time. Each can had to slide into a cooler box, with the first contestants to complete the challenge securing their place back on the island.

The first celebrity contestant and the first Smoooth Fan to finish would each earn their way back into the competition, with the two winners forming an entirely new team.

Ashay Sewlall emerged as the winning Smoooth Fan, while Olympic champion Caster Semenya claimed victory in the celebrity category. Their wins brought them back into the competition as the brand-new Team Orange.

The result, however, meant the end of the road for the remaining member of Team Pineapple (Wiseman Mncube) and Team Orange (Thando Zwane). This also meant that Team Mango Peach (Sandile Mahlangu and Jodell Tantij) and Team Green Apple (Nadia Nakai and Andile Khuluse) were eliminated from the competition, leaving the remaining contestants stunned by the dramatic shake-up.

The race for an advantage heated up

There was little time for the returning contestants to celebrate, as the remaining teams were thrown straight into another challenge: Memory Divers.

This time, teams had to swim out to five buoys, where contestants dived underwater to memorise three symbols at each station. Remembering the number, shape and colour of each symbol was crucial. Once they had gathered all the information, they had to swim back to shore and recreate the symbols on a puzzle board, arranging them in numerical order from 1 to 15.

Team Blueberry Cheesecake rose to the challenge, taking first place with four points. Team Tropical followed in second place with three points, while Team Peach claimed third with two points. Team Litchi finished fourth, earning one point, leaving the newly formed Team Orange in last place.

However, all was not lost for Caster and Ashay. The pair managed to find the Smoooth Charm, securing a valuable advantage heading into the next Mystery Box Challenge.

Tropika Island Of Treasure airs every Wednesday at 21:00 on SABC 1, with a repeat every Thursday at 18:00 on S3.

HAVE YOU READ THIS ONE?: EXCLUSIVE: Rosina Shiko Takes Her Limpopo Roots to Lagos in a Major African Entertainment Milestone

Avatar photo

By Asanda Mbayimbayi

Asanda Mbayimbayi is a multi-award-winning journalist, Lifestyle & Entertainment News Editor, and accomplished storyteller whose work spans digital lifestyle, entertainment, and hard news journalism. Recognised with the prestigious Galliova People's Hero Award in both 2025 and 2026, she has established a distinctive presence in the media landscape through authentic storytelling, editorial excellence, and an ability to connect compelling narratives with the audiences they serve. With a keen instinct for identifying stories that matter and a deep understanding of the relationship between media, culture, and audience engagement, Asanda approaches journalism with a commitment to substance, accuracy, and impact. Her editorial perspective combines the curiosity of an investigative mind with the sensitivity of a storyteller, bringing clarity to complex subjects and depth to stories that shape conversations. Beyond the newsroom, Asanda's expertise extends across research, content creation, production, book editing, and motivational speaking. A qualified Bible teacher, she also draws on her faith and spiritual insight to encourage reflection, personal growth, and meaningful transformation through words. Multifaceted by experience and purpose-driven by conviction, Asanda continues to explore the power of storytelling across platforms and disciplines. Whether shaping editorial narratives, developing compelling content, researching ideas, or inspiring audiences, her work reflects a commitment to thoughtful communication, creative excellence, and stories that leave a lasting impression. At the heart of her work is a belief that storytelling is more than the art of communicating information; it is a powerful tool for informing perspectives, amplifying voices, and creating meaningful connections.